TOPICS
Questionnaires
Surface
dressing
Motto
of the Month
|
Introduction
I am a bit late in wishing you a Happy New Year, but I will
do so all the same, Happy new Year.
The new year always seems to be a good time to me, a time when you can
start again if a new start is needed and perhaps proceed in a new
direction if the old ways are not working.
Note, I say if the old ways are not working, change for change sake is
pretty pointless in my opinion, especially if the methods you have
been using are not producing problems and are "getting you good
marks".
If I have to make a New Year's Resolution it would be "proceed
with care".
One other comment I might add, is, if you are going to make a mistake,
and we all do, let it be your own mistake and not that of somebody
else, make your own decisions.
Thinking you can take the advice, recommendations, of others and if it
all goes wrong you can pass on the blame is not a good idea, you will
suddenly find yourself very lonely.
So please use this website as means of increasing your knowledge so
that you may make good, or at least not bad decisions, but not as a
means of finding a definitive answer.
There is almost certainly more than one solution to any problem, but
it will be related to available budget, and according to the
"press" there could be less available money around for
highways maintenance in the near future.
Questionnaires
I am aware of two
questionnaires that are being circulated that may have a considerable
bearing on highways maintenance practices, and in my opinion those of
you employed in providing the service should be aware of them, as you
may wish to have an involvement.
The details of one questionnaire, relating to accidents involving
horse riding on the highway, is to be found on the website of the
British
Horse Society.
This initiative may help resolve the question as to whether bituminous
mixtures described as stone mastic asphalt (SMA) pose an increased
problem with regard to horses slipping while riding on the highway.
It is my opinion that some "ill conceived" statements are
being made in relation to this topic that do not take in to account
the considerable difference that there can be between bituminous
mixtures that come under a broad generic description.
There has been considerable coverage on this issue in engineering
journals over the past few years, if you are not aware of the
arguments you might like to do some reading.
The second questionnaire I think you should be aware of relates to the
possible introduction of a Code of Practice for Thin Surfacing.
A
contract to produce such a document has been awarded to W.S.Atkins and
further details can be obtained from the minutes of the meeting
of the "Northern Counties Soils and Materials Group" held on
the 6th. of October 2004.
A copy of these minutes can be downloaded in .pdf format from the
website of the CSS - County
Surveyors Society .
I will once again bring to your attention that the CSS has already
produced an extremely useful advice note on the use of proprietary
thin surfacings, and I recommend its perusal.
CSS - ENG 1/2003 - Advice note for the specification of Thin Surfacing
As I recall it costs just £10:00 and is available from CSS members at
Lincolnshire County Council.
It does note seem unreasonable to me that the proposed Code of
Practice should be part of the Guidelines Document for the Approval of
Thin Surfacing Systems produced by the British Board of Agrément (BBA).
This document being the means by which proprietary Thin Surfacing
Systems receive Highway Authority Product Approval
(HAPAS).
As far as I am aware the Guidelines Document is still in draft form
seven years after it was introduced. It would not be unreasonable to
ask how many of you who are purchasing very large amounts of thin
surfacing at substantial cost have seen a draft Guidelines
Document and know what it contains.
Perhaps we could bring together the Guideline Document from the BBA,
the existing Advice Note from the CSS, and the new work being done for
the Code of Practice by W.S.Atkins.
It follows we might like to involve the British Standards Institute
(BSI) and produce a comprehensive British Standard for Thin Surfacing
Systems that everybody will adhere to.
Or, we could just use the various bituminous mixture standards that already
exist, including ratifying the draft BS EN standards that have not yet
been been ratified in the UK.
Some of these drafts must be close to
five years old, the period I understand if exceeded should result in
automatic ratification of the particular draft in all European
countries.
One last point, if you need examples of what a Code of Practice for
Thin Surfacings ought to contain look no further than BS 594, parts
one and two, and BS 4987, also both parts, for inspiration.
You will need a knowledgeable Materials Engineer to understand some of
the points I raise, not having such a person does not mean you can
ignore the items I discuss, these subjects will affect you sooner or
later.
Surface
dressing
This is just a
quick note to bring to your attention to a matter, that by the time you
read this the deadline to make comments will probably have passed.
I refer to the publication of Draft EN 12271 -
Surface Dressing.
I find this a very comprehensive document covering most aspects
of the process of surface dressing, but not the design. Some may say
it is too comprehensive. It is well worth a read, and although only
draft it is well worth the price of £10:00 (if you are a BSI member)
if only for the considerable amount of information it contains
relating to the surface dressing process.
However if you wish to make comments on its content you had better be
quick because the closing date for submissions is the 31st. of
January.
Motto of the Month
"There is a certain
relief in change, even though it be from bad to worse, it is often a
comfort to shift one's position and be bruised in a new place."
|